In case you needed more proof that none of these shows are real, Thomas admitted that Suspect wasn’t even the show for which he originally auditioned: In the series premiere, Allen suspects his best friend is hiding an illness & Kristen is concerned her step-brother (Thomas) is binge-drinking. Nev from Catfish & his co-host iO travel across America investigating secret suspicions. Thomas Rigg) was apparently cast with his step-sister (Kristen) because he might be alcoholic, or something. The “reality” show about people with so-called secrets premieres tomorrow night, and Logan (a.k.a. The show hasn’t even aired yet, but thanks to several readers who tipped me to Randy Blue performer Logan Milano’s appearance on MTV’s Suspect.